
Person. Role. System
Why leadership problems aren’t always leadership problems.
When something isn’t working in a leadership team, we tend to jump straight to the person. They need to delegate more, communicate better, be more strategic, less reactive, more confident, better at holding people to account. Sometimes that’s absolutely right, but sometimes we’re trying to fix the person when the problem is actually the role they’re trying to perform, or the system they’re trying to perform it in.
This distinction becomes particularly important in a fast-growing business because almost everything is changing at once. The organisation is getting bigger, roles are becoming more complex, expectations are shifting and the informal ways of working that got you through the startup phase are starting to creak. At the same time, people are being asked to lead at a level they may never have operated at before.
It’s very easy, in that environment, to interpret every difficulty as a capability gap. Sometimes it is and sometimes it really isn’t.
At Third House, we look at leadership through three lenses: Person, Role and System. They give us a way of understanding what’s actually going on before we rush in and start trying to fix it.
Start with the person
The first place to look is the obvious one: the human being doing the job. Who are they? What are they naturally good at? What gives them energy? What knocks their confidence? How do they behave under pressure? What are the beliefs and assumptions sitting underneath the decisions they make?
All of this matters because leadership is deeply personal. Two people can be given exactly the same role, in exactly the same organisation, and experience it completely differently. One person sees ambiguity as freedom, another finds it deeply uncomfortable. One thrives on pace, another wants more time to think. One naturally trusts people until given a reason not to, another wants evidence before they let go.
None of those things makes somebody inherently better or worse as a leader, but they do shape the leadership they provide. The really interesting part is that many of the difficulties we see in senior leaders come from strengths rather than weaknesses.
The leader who cares deeply about quality starts checking everything. The person who is brilliant at moving quickly becomes impatient when the organisation can’t keep pace with them. The founder whose instinct and attention to detail helped build the business struggles to stop being involved in every decision. The empathetic leader avoids giving somebody the feedback they really need because they don’t want to damage the relationship.
A strength used in the wrong context, or turned up too high, can become just as problematic as a genuine development gap. Which is why self-awareness is so important. If you understand your own patterns, you have more choice over whether to follow them.
But understanding the person is only the beginning.
Next we need to look at the role…
The role itself is the bit that gets missed surprisingly often. What does the role actually require? Not what it required two years ago, not what the previous person did, and not what happens to be sitting in somebody’s diary. What does the business need from this role now?
This question becomes particularly important during periods of high change like significant growth because roles can change enormously without anyone consciously redesigning them.
Take a founder CEO. In the early stages of the business, their job may have been almost everything: winning clients, shaping the product, hiring people, solving problems, keeping an eye on the cash and deciding whether the printer really needed replacing.
As the business grows, none of those things necessarily disappears, but the CEO’s relationship with them has to change. Their value increasingly comes from setting direction, making the few decisions only they can make, building the right leadership team, allocating resources, maintaining alignment and making sure the organisation has what it needs for the next phase.
That sounds obvious written down but it can feel anything but obvious when you’re living it.
The work that has always made you feel useful is still there. You can see it, you know how to do it and often you can do it faster than the person now responsible for it. Meanwhile, some of the work you are supposed to be doing at the new level feels far less tangible: thinking, looking ahead, building relationships, creating clarity, developing people and holding the bigger picture.
It is hardly surprising that people drift back towards the work that gives them an immediate sense of achievement.
The same thing happens throughout a scaling leadership team. A functional director who was once rewarded for being the best technical expert now needs to lead other experts. A head of department who used to make all the important decisions now has managers underneath them who need the space to make those decisions themselves. A member of the leadership team has to stop representing their function exclusively and start taking collective responsibility for the whole business.
These are significant changes in role. If we don’t make them explicit, we can spend an extraordinary amount of time trying to coach people out of behaviours that their environment is still encouraging.
One of the simplest questions we ask leaders is, “What is your job now?” It is usually followed fairly quickly by another: “And what is no longer your job?” That second question tends to be harder.
But what about the system?
Finally, there is the system around the leader. By system, we don’t mean a giant corporate process map, we mean the everyday operating environment people are trying to lead and operate within.
We can understand the system by thinking about how are decisions made. Who has authority to make them? How does information move around the organisation? What happens in meetings? How clear are the priorities? How are roles defined? What gets escalated? What happens when somebody makes the wrong call?
This gives us clarity on where accountability actually sits and what behaviours get rewarded and what gets tolerated.
These things have an enormous effect on how the organisation runs.
Imagine a CEO who is constantly getting dragged into operational decisions. The obvious diagnosis might be that they need to delegate, and perhaps they do but what if nobody in the team knows who has authority to make those decisions? What if the leadership team keeps escalating things because previous mistakes have been punished? What if roles overlap so heavily that nobody is entirely sure who owns what? What if every meeting ends with a vague sense of agreement but no clear decision?
Suddenly the CEO’s involvement looks less like a personality problem and more like a system problem.
Likewise, you can tell somebody to be more strategic until you are blue in the face, but if they spend seven hours a day in back-to-back operational meetings, there is a fairly obvious structural barrier standing in their way.
We see this a lot in fast-growth businesses. The organisation has grown, but the operating system hasn’t. What once worked beautifully with 15 people becomes chaotic with 50. Informal conversations stop reaching everyone. Decisions become slower. Accountability gets fuzzy. Meetings multiply to compensate. Senior leaders get pulled down into the detail because the structure underneath them hasn’t caught up.
Then everybody starts wondering why the leadership team has become so operational.
For us, the real work starts where the three things meet. The real value of Person, Role, System is not looking at each element independently, it is looking at the relationship between them.
A leader may be perfectly capable but operating in a poorly defined role. A role may be beautifully designed but completely wrong for the person sitting in it. A talented leadership team may still struggle because the system around them makes alignment unnecessarily difficult. Or all three may be slightly off, which is usually where things start to feel particularly messy.
This is why generic leadership development can be so frustrating. If you assume every problem lives in the person, you naturally reach for skills training: communications workshops, delegation training, time management, difficult conversations. All of those things can be useful, but none of them will solve a badly designed role or a system that continually rewards the wrong behaviour.
The challenge is to diagnose before you prescribe.
Leadership development in a high change environment has to go beyond teaching people how to lead, you have to make sure you are developing the right people for the right roles inside a system that gives them a fighting chance of succeeding.
At Third House, this is one of the ways we help founders, CEOs and leadership teams get clarity on what is really standing in the way of growth. We look at the person, the role and the system together, rather than assuming the person needs fixing.
Because sometimes the best leadership intervention isn’t another leadership course. Sometimes it’s simply getting your house in order.
If you’re leading a fast-growing business and something feels harder than it should, get in touch at rebecca@wearethirdhouse.com.
Take the leadership snapshot
We’ve put some questions together to see if our leadership support would benefit you and your business. It won’t take long, but it will give you plenty to think about.
Ringing true?
Let’s have a chat.
